First Date·Old Fourth Ward·$$ · Moderate·⭐ 7.8

Il Premio

Archived listing — current status, hours, and prices need verification. This venue is not in the checked planner collection.

Italian-American charm in a neighborhood that's still figuring itself out — and that's exactly why it works.

Check location and hours →Find menu and reservations →

Confirm current hours, menu prices, and availability with the venue before heading out. Scores are DatingDex editorial estimates, not customer review averages.

What DatingDex says

Il Premio hits the sweet spot between effort and approachability — pasta that gives you something to talk about, a room that doesn't try too hard, and Old Fourth Ward energy that keeps things feeling current without the attitude. Solid first date move when you want to look like you did your research without making the whole night feel like a job interview.

Il Premio is one of the top first date spots in Old Fourth Ward. At a moderate price point, it fits well when you want a first date feel without guesswork.

More first date spots in Old Fourth Ward

First Date
Editorial 8.6
Old Fourth Ward·$$
a mano
Wood-fired, low-key, and somehow always the right call.
A Mano is an Old Fourth Ward staple that punches above its price point — handmade pasta, a tight natural wine list, and a room loud enough to keep things lively without drowning conversation. It signals effort without screaming 'I Googled best date spots Atlanta.'
First Date
Editorial 7.8
Old Fourth Ward·$$
Amore e Amore
Italian charm without the pretension — Old Fourth Ward's most underrated date spot
Amore e Amore hits the sweet spot between effort and approachability — good pasta, warm lighting, and a N. Highland address that says you know the neighborhood without trying too hard. The name is a little earnest but the room earns it.
First Date
Editorial 8.3
Old Fourth Ward·$$
Yeppa & Co. - Beltline
O4W's most charming wildcard — casual enough to breathe, good enough to brag about later.
Yeppa & Co. sits right in the sweet spot between trying too hard and not trying at all — a 4.9 with 3,000+ reviews doesn't lie, and the Beltline-adjacent location means you've got a built-in 'want to walk?' move after the meal. Come hungry, come curious, skip the reservation anxiety.
First Date
Editorial 8.3
Old Fourth Ward·$$
Kitty Dare
O4W's most charming corner for a drink that turns into three.
Kitty Dare hits the sweet spot between effort and ease — a thoughtful cocktail bar on Edgewood with just enough personality to give you something to talk about. The kind of place where you show up for one drink and realize an hour later you've been deep in conversation without noticing the time.
First Date
Editorial 7.8
Old Fourth Ward·$$
Indaco
Italian done right in the neighborhood everyone's trying to live in.
Indaco pulls off a genuinely good Italian menu — think handmade pasta and wood-fired everything — without the stuffiness that usually comes with it. O4W foot traffic keeps the energy social, but the interior is put-together enough that it reads as intentional effort, not a random Tuesday.
First Date
Editorial 7.8
Old Fourth Ward·$$
Atrium - American Bistro & Martini Bar
Martinis and mood lighting in the middle of Ponce City Market's best-kept floor
Atrium pulls off something tricky — it's inside a mall but doesn't feel like it, with enough bistro warmth and a serious martini list to make the night feel intentional. The 4.7 rating across nearly 2K reviews isn't an accident; this place consistently delivers without demanding you dress up or break the bank.