First Date·East Village·$$$ · Upscale·⭐ 7.6

Mayamezcal

Archived listing — current status, hours, and prices need verification. This venue is not in the checked planner collection.

Mezcal and mole in the East Village — date night with actual personality.

Check location and hours →Find menu and reservations →

Confirm current hours, menu prices, and availability with the venue before heading out. Scores are DatingDex editorial estimates, not customer review averages.

What DatingDex says

Mayamezcal brings serious mezcal depth and refined Mexican cooking to a stretch of 6th Street that earns every dollar of that $$$ tag. The candlelit interior does the heavy lifting atmospherically, but it's the drink list — agave-forward cocktails and a mezcal selection that rewards curiosity — that keeps the conversation going.

Mayamezcal is one of the top first date spots in East Village. At a upscale price point, it fits well when you want a first date feel without guesswork.

More first date spots in East Village

First Date
Editorial 7.7
East Village·$$
AURA Tapas & Cocktail Bar
Tapas and tension — the East Village edition
AURA pulls off the rare trick of feeling like a real neighborhood bar while still having enough intention behind it to signal you put thought into the pick. Small plates mean shared food, shared food means chemistry testing — order the patatas bravas and see how they handle splitting the last one.
First Date
Editorial 7.7
East Village·$$
Gnocco
Italian comfort with East Village edge — dinner that doesn't try too hard.
Gnocco pulls off the rare trick of feeling genuinely neighborhood without being sloppy about it — the back garden is the real move in warmer months, and the pillowy namesake fritters with prosciutto are worth ordering before you've even looked at the menu. It's the kind of place where the second glass of wine happens naturally.
First Date
Editorial 7.9
East Village·$$
Tuome
East Village refinement without the pretension tax
Tuome threads the needle between neighborhood spot and destination restaurant — the kind of place where the food is genuinely impressive (get the smoked salmon dip and whatever pork dish is on the menu) but nobody's making you feel underdressed. The room is warm and unfussy, the tables are spaced just right, and a $$ price tag for this level of cooking is quietly doing a lot of work for your first impression.
First Date
Editorial 7.7
East Village·$$
Gemma
Italian-ish comfort food with just enough downtown edge to feel like you picked well
Gemma sits inside the Bowery Hotel lobby, which sounds weird until you're actually there — dark wood, candlelight, and a menu of solid pastas and roast chicken that nobody's going to stress over. It's the kind of place where the effort is obvious but the vibe stays relaxed, and that's a hard balance to pull off on Bowery.
First Date
Editorial 7.7
East Village·$$
Superbueno
Loud, fun, and agave-forward — order the frozen drink and stop overthinking it.
Superbueno brings a punchy, maximalist energy to the East Village with a menu that leans hard into Mexican spirits and snackable bites — think al pastor tostadas and mezcal cocktails that taste like they were designed to lower inhibitions responsibly. It's buzzy enough that an awkward silence disappears into the room, but not so chaotic that you're texting instead of talking.
First Date
Editorial 7.7
East Village·$$
The Wayland
East Village warmth without the East Village attitude
The Wayland earns its 4.6 the honest way — good cocktails, candlelight that flatters everyone, and a room that's lively enough to ease nerves but not so loud you're reading lips. The Aviary and other amaro-forward drinks give you something to actually talk about.