First Date·West Village·$$ · Moderate·⭐ 8.0

Donna

Archived listing — current status, hours, and prices need verification. This venue is not in the checked planner collection.

West Village magic in a bottle — literally.

Check location and hours →Find menu and reservations →

Confirm current hours, menu prices, and availability with the venue before heading out. Scores are DatingDex editorial estimates, not customer review averages.

What DatingDex says

Donna does the whole 'intimate tropical bar' thing without being annoying about it — the rum cocktails are serious, the Cornelia Street address does half the romantic work for you, and the lighting is dim enough to be flattering without feeling like you're hiding something. It's a first date that signals taste without the pretension tax of a Michelin-adjacent spot.

Donna is one of the top first date spots in West Village. At a moderate price point, it fits well when you want a first date feel without guesswork.

More first date spots in West Village

First Date
Editorial 8.0
West Village·$$
The Mary Lane
West Village charm without the West Village attitude
The Mary Lane threads the needle between neighborhood bar and actual restaurant — the kind of place where you can order a second drink without feeling like you're overstaying a coffee, or linger over food without the check being dropped on you passive-aggressively. Bank Street's relative quiet means you arrive already feeling like you found something worth finding.
First Date
Editorial 7.8
West Village·$$
Rosemary's
Farm-to-table effort that doesn't lecture you about it
Rosemary's earns its West Village real estate with a rooftop herb garden that actually supplies the kitchen and Italian-leaning plates that feel considered without being precious. The room is lively enough that awkward silences dissolve, but not so loud you're reading lips by the second glass of wine.
First Date
Editorial 7.8
West Village·$$
MiGarba NYC
West Village charm with something actually worth talking about on the menu.
MiGarba earns its Bleecker St address without coasting on it — the food gives you something to lean into conversation-wise, and the room doesn't try too hard. Good for when you want to signal effort without the stiffness of a reservation-required tasting menu.
First Date
Editorial 7.8
West Village·$$
Felice on Hudson
West Village wine bar that actually earns the neighborhood hype.
Felice on Hudson pulls off the rare trick of feeling both polished and unpretentious — the Italian wine list is serious without being intimidating, and the small plates give you something to talk about besides yourselves. Hudson Street foot traffic keeps it lively, but the interior has enough warmth to make it feel like your own corner of the city.
First Date
Editorial 7.8
West Village·$$
Libertine
West Village wine bar energy without the pretension tax
Libertine earns its name — relaxed enough that you're not performing, but curated enough that showing up here says something. The natural wine list does the heavy lifting on personality, and the Greenwich St corner location means you've got the whole West Village as your after-drink plan.
First Date
Editorial 8.0
West Village·$$
OLIO E PIÙ
West Village Italian that earns its reputation without trying too hard
Olio e Più pulls off the tricky balance of feeling special without being precious — the wood-fired pizza and burrata are legitimately good, the room has warm candlelight and exposed brick, and the Greenwich Ave corner spot means you're already in the best neighborhood in the city for a post-dinner walk. It's not trying to be a scene, which is exactly why it works.